Fascinating convo! I’m playing an Urban Shadows Vamp at the moment and trying to work out a balance between mechanically pursuing people for my Web, and portraying my character with fictional motivations. It’s hard and I never quite framed it like y’all are discussing.
Looks like this issue at the system-level in Legacy would break some groups. Oh for the days when PbtA was fiction-first, ’twas a simpler time. 😛