Paul Beakley , I think I’m perhaps contrasting my experience too much with the Ronnies, which have almost identical rules (ingredients, usually no theme), but produce much more polished and interesting games- although there are less of them.

I don’t know what the solution is to weed out entries that read like they were ripped from TimeCube.  Maybe there shouldn’t be, and maybe that’s useful feedback: “I can’t understand your game.”